Threshold, the new CBS show co-executive produced by Brannon Braga and co-starring Brent Spiner, received only mediocre ratings for its premiere.
The new series earned a 5.3 rating/9 share in the fast national ratings for CBS, according to Zap2It. This means that approximately 5.3% of American households with television sets were tuned to CBS during the 9 p.m. hour, representing 9% of households watching television at that time. The second hour of NBC’s Dateline took the top spot, although Threshold finished ahead of UPN’s Smackdown! with a 3.2/6, the WB’s season premieres of Reba and Living with Fran with an average 2.2/4, ABC’s Hope & Faith and Less Than Perfect which tied the WB numbers and FOX in last place with a rerun of the Reunion premiere.
NBC averaged a 6.0 rating/11 share in primetime for the night, beating the 5.2/9 for CBS, although the Eye network was top-rated among adults 18-49. Dateline’s ratings also went up from the 8 p.m. hour to the 9 p.m. hour, starting out with a 5.3/10 and improving to a 6.9/12 against Threshold, which improved in its second hour to a 5.6/10.
Reviews had largely been positive, with DailyPress.com calling Threshold “frighteningly good.” Called the best of the Lost parallels, Threshold is praised for its “gasp-out-loud scary” story. Newsday called the new series “not for the young or squeamish”, noting, “It’s no surprise to learn the sci-fi suspenser ‘Threshold’ is being produced by ‘Star Trek’ spin-offs veteran Brannon Braga.” The paper did not believe that Spiner’s role was in the new series’ best interest, however, saying, “Casting Brent Spiner in a quirky role does not a youthful stew make. ‘Trek’ itself is old news now, and the notion CBS doesn’t know that does not bode well for a concept that might otherwise be enlivened into something worth watching again.”